Millions of years ago, humans began documenting the world around them. They found several ways to do this. They painted on rock walls, both outside and inside caves, depicting aspects of their lives, including the animals they encountered. They carved figurines and painted their bowls and tools. They painted their bodies. When they learned language, they told stories about life from one generation to the next.
Today, among many other ways, we have film, video, and photography to tell stories and document the world around us. This book chronicles documentaries on a wide range of subjects. It reviews and reflects on these stories – their subjects, how they were recorded, and perhaps why.
If you want to tell nonfiction stories in a documentary style, you will find examples to help you choose a style and genre. Watch and study these documentaries.
If you enjoy documentaries, you will find some of the best in this book.
Our purpose is to explore the world of documentary films and other media, review and reflect on the subject, production methods, and how effectively they communicate their stories to us. Will they last as long as those paintings on the walls of caves in France and elsewhere? Time will tell. In the interim, you can decide for yourself.
“In a seemingly paradoxical way, the monks of Shaolin, the birthplace of Chinese Zen and Kung Fu, pursue Buddhist peace and enlightenment. The film examines the life of the young boys, monks, and others at the monastery through the year’s seasons.” Written and Directed by Hongyun Sun, Ph.D., Beijing Film Academy.” –
“Director Sun’s film showcases life in the Shaolin Monastery, the birthplace of Chinese Chan and Kung Fu. She follows several monks and a Ph.D. candidate conducting fieldwork to explore the philosophy of peace and enlightenment through martial arts. It depicts their daily meditation, martial arts practice routines, and challenges outside the temple. The film portrays the realities of their lives and unwavering commitment to their chosen path, featuring ordinary mortals instead of Kung Fu heroes or Saint Monks.”
Into the Shaolin, a feature-length documentary has finished production at the Shaolin Temple in China. Shaolin is the birthplace of Kung Fu and Ch’an Buddhism, a cultural mecca for many followers in China and worldwide. The documentary is directed by Hongyun Sun of Beijing Film Academy in China. The documentary is being screened in film festivals worldwide.
The Into the Shaolin Story
Within the ancient monastery and daily rituals, Into the Shaolin documentary delves into the unknown personal experiences of modern monks and others at the Shaolin Temple. In today’s world, where the Internet plays a prominent role, the connection between the monks of Shaolin and the outside world has changed. There are new conflicts and resolutions concerning traditional customs, Chinese Ch’an (Zen is a branch of Ch’an outside China), love, fame, fortune, and Kung Fu practice.
Xiao Shami
Heng Kun’s father died at a young age. His mother remarried, keeping his younger brother and sending young Heng Kun to Shaolin Temple to study. He became Xiao Shami, excellent at Kung Fu with the Shaolin Temple Wushu Group. The Internet brought him Into contact with his mother, who he misses. He loves his life at Shaolin but wants to explore the outside world and possibly reconnect with his mother and brother.
Shi Yanzi and Marta Neskovic
Shi Yanzi, a Shaolin Temple farmer, was born in 1978. He has been the head of the Shaolin Temple Wushu Regiment. Master Yanzi actively practices a style of farming meditation at Shaolin Temple. He organically combined farming and Ch’an culture. Four brothers and sisters in Yanzi’s family followed him to Shaolin. Shi Yanzi, Ch’an cultivates the 800 acres at Shaolin Temple year-round. He has strong notions about Ch’an Buddhism and farming.
Marta Neskovic, a 26-year-old doctoral student from the University of Belgrade in Serbia, studies at Shaolin Temple. She dresses in gray garments like the monks and students. She practices Kung Fu and learns Ch’an Buddhism and the Chinese language. At the same time, she is working on her thesis. Marta’s story is about adjusting to life at Shaolin and keeping in tune with her family and friends.
Shi Yanzhuang
Shi Yanzhuang is the general coach of the Washu group at Shaolin. His martial arts, Wei Zhen Shaolin, and performances have been praised globally. His philosophy brings Ch’an practice to the external performance of Kung Fu.
Some monks at Shaolin are orphans who find their way to the temple.
Shi Yanyong
“Who am I?” Shi Yanyong does not know his birthday, has no parents, and does not know his exact age. At ten, he followed a Taoist priest from Yunnan-Guizhou Plateau to Shaolin Temple, where the priest abandoned him. He grew up at Shaolin. Encouraged by the Abbot, he accomplished many things, from Kung Fu and meditation to poetry and living in the mountains. His life and search for identity are part of the story of Into the Shaolin.
These Shaolin residents and others have unique stories about their lives at Shaolin. They relate what it means to them, the conflicts, struggles, and who they are now. These compelling, interweaving stories reveal much about contemporary life today at Shaolin Temple. Set against the pallet of culture and history of Shaolin Temple, they paint a vivid picture few have seen.
Watching the documentary film, “ruth weiss: the beat goddess” you can’t help but fall in love with “ruth.” She is a contemporary of Kerouac, Ferlinghetti, Ginsberg, Burroughs, and others. Why is her name not familiar? You start to wonder why she has been a stranger all these years. The obvious answer is quite simple as “ruth” and the documentary will inform us. In the 1950’s women poets did not get published or given any attention. The film documents “ruth’s” life and work at the same time as it explores significant moments in social and literary movements beginning with the “beat generation.”
“ruth” in San Francisco 1950’s
“ruth weiss: the beat goddess,“ is a well-made contemporary documentary, directed by Melody C. Miller introducing “ruth weiss,” her life’s work and sojourn. It is a biography and an exploration of the world “ruth” lived in from her birth in Germany, in the year 1928 to her death in California in 2020. The narrator of the film is “ruth weiss.” Her story. It appears that she was interviewed and also filmed reading and/or performing her work with a trio of musicians when she was in her late 80’s. She is seen in the film reading her poetry at a Women’s March in 2019 at the age of 91. ”ruth” is articulate and a great storyteller. People who know about her life add commentary and insight. “Herb Caen dubbed “ruth weiss” as ‘The Goddess of the Beat Generation.”
Watch the trailer:
“ruth” read her poetry with jazz musicians early on. “In the 1950’s, she organized the first poetry readings in North Beach cafes and bars providing a platform to many poets.” The documentary reveals that she was among the very first “beat poets” reading her work to Jazz. Casual friends, she and Jack Kerouac exchanged writing Haiku poems before he became famous with “On the Road.”
The documentary uses creative imagery to accompany some of her poetry visualizing historic moments in “ruth’s” life. It has animated recreations of past events done in an artistic style by Ketai Rivera an Bijiao Liu. Certain poems read by “ruth” are heard as a modern dancer performs interpretive, moving visual imagery. Music also brings to life the poetry, while “ruth” performs with a trio of jazz musicians in many scenes or reads voice over to music. In addition to the live video the film makes extensive use of archival photographs of “ruth” and events during her life. This story is entertaining and greatly informative. Anyone interested in poetry and the social impact of the “beat generation,” must watch this film.
Melody C. Miller directed, shot, and edited this documentary which has won numerous awards. Recently it received the 2020 Maverick Spirit Award from the Cinequest Film Festival given to influential individuals who embody the independent and innovative mindset. Previously awarded to Werner Herzog, Harrison Ford, Jackie Chan and many others.
“A beautiful and atmospheric celebration of a creative soul, ruth weiss: the beat goddess will be streaming on Apple TV, Amazon Prime, Tubi, Xumo, Plex, Google TV, Hulu, Kinema, Kanopy, and more from ruth weiss’ birthday on June 24, 2022, and available on PBS channels on August 28th, 2022. “
Happy Birthday “ruth weiss!”
Review by James R Martin, writer, documentary filmmaker.
Have you ever wondered why certain successful, wealthy, celebrities get to a point in their lives where they choose to take their own lives? Road Runner – A Film About Anthony Bourdain, directed by Morgan Neville might shed some light on how someone gets to this point in their life.
One Controversial issue regarding the film.
While this film uses a documentary format it has a one distracting difference. In several places it uses voice over created to sound like Bourdain created by an artificial intelligence program that learns to mimic human voices. Nowhere in the film does it mention that Bourdain’s voice is synthetic in places. A modest subtitle when this occurs could have solved any problem in this regard. It is presented in such a way that the audience might think that Bourdain said these things. Apparently, he never said these words aloud, he wrote them down, at least in one instance.
There is a false notion that real documentaries are somehow objective. Documentaries are not objective; they are subjective by default because they are made by humans. All documentaries have a point-of-view. Having an actor read voice over to narrate a film does not make it fiction because narrators are identified, and the audience knows what is being said is narration. But once a documentary filmmaker begins to “re-create” scenes, or use actors to play characters in the film, it becomes fiction. Is voice over created by AI software to imitate a character in the film using an actor? It makes one wonder what else in the film might be manipulated beyond actuality.
The Story
The documentary Road Runner begins with the fact that Bourdain took his own life on June 8, 2018, a few weeks before his 62nd birthday on June 25th. He hung himself in France while working on a new television series. Since this fact is known by all, it seems like a good idea to get it out of the way and go back into Bourdain’s past to learn who he was and how he got to this point in his life. Bourdain’s journey as a chef, television food show host, and celebrity is traced through interviews with family, friends, colleagues, and through the use of archival footage. During the one hour-fifty-eight-minute story we first meet young Anthony Bourdain who essentially begins to narrate his own life story. As time progresses the viewer gets to know Bourdain through his actions, words, family and good friends. By the end of the story perhaps there is some insight into Bourdain’s melancholy, the reason and method of ending his life.
Trailer
Road Runner, A Film about Anthony Bourdain is a strong documentary that lets the viewer get to know Bourdain in many ways. Bourdain was a talented, intelligent person who evolved over the years in different ways. We follow him through two marriages and the joy of being a parent. Later in life an affair that caused him to take a strong advocacy position publicly.
Throughout his life Bourdain seemed somewhat overwhelmed by his success even though he stepped up and learned quickly to deal with each new phase. The personality seen on the television series was the real Bourdain, but he had another private side to that personality that he shared with his close friends and family. It is clear from the beginning of the documentary that there is a romantic side to Bourdain that comes out in his writing and personal relationships. He enjoyed celebrity but in some ways like an observer of his own fame.
A Documentary Worth Seeing
Road Runner, A Film About Anthony Bourdain, directed by Morgan Neville is worth seeing. It is a well edited story that keeps pace with Bourdain’s constantly moving style of life. Over many decades Bourdain spent most of his time traveling 250 or so days per year. The film shows behind the scenes views of those days of “gathering frequent flyer miles,” as Bourdain alludes to on one occasion. For anyone who watched Bourdain on television, read his books or followed his career it offers a deeper understanding of the man and his travels. The film brings insight into celebrity, success and its impact on one person’s life.
Review by James R Martin, documentary writer/director, author.
America, first met Michelle Obama as the wife of Presidential Candidate Barack Obama and then as First Lady. Over the next eight years she became one of the most admired First Lady’s in history. This biographical documentary explores who Michelle Obama was before that time and who she has become more recently. Michelle Obama: Life after the White House is a well-made insightful story written, directed and edited by Jordan Hill, about Michelle Robinson Obama growing up in South Chicago, her education at Princeton and Harvard Law School, her law career and ultimately her meeting Barack Obama. Followed by life in the White House and life afterward. Why today she remains extremely popular and well regarded for her achievements.
Documentary film biographies may take a number of forms. Michelle Obama: Life after the White House looks at her public persona and her transition from private life to public. The documentary appears to be drawn, in part, from Michelle Obama’s book Becoming Michelle Obama. The film, like the book looks at Michelle Obama’s roots, how she found her voice and her role as a Mother and First Lady. Becoming was published in 24 languages. It was the highest selling book published in the United States in 2018. One million copies were donated to First Book an organization that provides books to children.
The documentary film Michelle Obama: Life after the White House uses past and more recent interviews with her and others. Also, public and televised appearances of Michele Obama, commentary by a number of people including journalist Ashley Pearson and Professor Natasha Lindstaedt. There is extensive use of archival photographs dating back to Michelle’s youth. She talks about the major influence of her parents and family on her and her life. How her parents encouraged her to find her path though education. Now a mother herself Michelle Obama carries on the tradition with her daughters.
Michelle Obama’s parents and extended family are middle and working-class people who passed on the value of education and work ethics. The film explores her dedication and motivations for her progress and life choices. This includes her meeting and ultimately marrying Barack Obama. At the time she was a lawyer working for a top Chicago law firm, where Obama was hired after graduating from Harvard law school himself. The film looks at how their relationship developed. Michelle is wife, friend and trusted advisor.
The documentary discovers how Michelle had to make some adjustments to her public image as the Presidential candidate’s wife and later as First Lady. It is interesting because the film shows that this transition was mostly Michelle becoming herself, educated, warm, funny at times, and sincere. Michele’s warmth and friendliness is demonstrated in one instance when even though no one is supposed to touch the Queen of England, the Queen welcomed Michelle putting her arm around her. The queen responded by reaching around to hold Michelle. Later she invited Michelle to share her car, even thought that also is taboo.
There is a good blend of interviews, photographs, and action used to tell the story. Two key commentators help narrate the story along with others who have come to know Michelle Obama. Editing is well paced.The documentary makes use of archival family photographs and other photographs to help tell the story. Also, some footage of Barrack and Michelle Obama, including his speaking at an event about Michelle that is quite moving. Michelle Obama: Life after the White House is an interesting, entertaining and uplifting, biographical documentary about a person, a confident woman who is inspirational to all, but in particular to young women who can look to Michelle Obama as a role model in their lives.
Legacy Distribution Synopsis: “Former First Lady MICHELLE OBAMA’S story has just begun. The Obama’s have remained quite busy with their new life of activism which includes their issue-oriented production company, Higher Ground, which won an Oscar for Best Documentary in 2020. Mrs. Obama’s autobiography, Becoming, has become the best-selling memoir of all time and even won a Grammy following the publication of her book. Get lost in the incredible journey of this modern-day First Lady’s story in the making.”
The feature-length biography is now widely available, including Amazon Prime: https://amzn.to/2XqTne5
DocumentaryReview by James R (Jim) Martin
James R (Jim) Martin is an Emmy, award winning producer, writer, director of film, television, video, multimedia and digital media productions. He has lectured on documentary subjects internationally. Most recently in several universities and forums in China. He directed the documentary filmmaking course at Full Sail University in Winter Park, Florida. He has taught directing at University of Central Florida and Film Production at Columbia College in Chicago.
Author: Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia – Third Edition 2014, Actuality Interviewing and Listening – 2017, Listen Learn Share, 2018, Documentary Directing and Storytelling, 2019. Editing Documentary and Fiction, to be published soon.
Directing Credits include two Emmy nominations and an Emmy Award for PBS documentary – Fired-up Public Housing is My Home. The Chicago Film Festival Golden Plaque for Best Network Documentary for Emmy nominee, Wrapped In Steel, also seen nationally on PBS stations. Telly Award 2018, JP’s Wish documentary, Make-a-Wish Foundation.
The Into the Shaolin, a feature length documentary, is finished production at Shaolin Temple in China. Shaolin is the birthplace of Kung Fu and Ch’an Buddhism, a cultural mecca for many followers in China and around the world. The documentary is directed by Hongyun Sun of Beijing Film Academy in China. The documentary is being screened in film festivals worldwide.
The Into the Shaolin Story
Within the ancient monastery and daily rituals, Into the Shaolin documentary delves into the unknown personal experiences of modern monks and others at Shaolin Temple. In today’s world, where the Internet plays so a large a role, the connection between the monks of Shaolin and the outside world has changed. There are new conflicts and resolutions concerning traditional customs, Chinese Ch’an (Zen is a branch of Ch’an outside China), love, fame, fortune and Kung Fu practice.
Xiao Shami
Heng
Kun’s father died at a young age. His mother remarried keeping his younger brother
and sending young Heng Kun to Shaolin Temple to study. He became Xiao Shami,
excellent at Kung Fu with the Shaolin Temple Wushu Group. The Internet brought
him Into contact with his mother, who he misses. He loves his life at Shaolin
but wants to explore the outside world and possibly reconnect with his mother
and brother.
Shi Yanzi and Marta Neskovic
Shi Yanzi, a Shaolin Temple farmer, was born in 1978. He has been the head of the Shaolin Temple Wushu Regiment. Master Yanzi actively practices a style of farming meditation at Shaolin Temple. He organically combined farming and Ch’an culture. Four, of the brothers and sisters in Yanzi’s family, followed him to Shaolin. Shi Yanzi, Ch’an cultivates the 800 acres at Shaolin Temple year round. He has strong notions about Ch’an Buddhism and farming.
Marta Neskovic, a 26 year old doctoral student from the University of Belgrade in Serbia studies at Shaolin Temple. She dresses in gray garments like the monks and students. She practices Kung Fu, learns Ch’an Buddhism and Chinese language. At the same time she is working on her thesis. Marta’s story is one of adjusting to life at Shaolin and also keeping in tune with her family and friends.
Shi Yanzhuang
Shi Yanzhuang, is general coach of the Washu group at Shaolin. His martial arts, Wei Zhen Shaolin, and his performances have been praised many times globally. His philosophy brings Ch’an practice to the external performance of Kung Fu.
Some monks at Shaolin are orphans who find there way to the temple.
Shi Yanyong
“Who am I?” Shi Yanyong does not know his birthday, has no parents, does not know his exact age. At ten, he followed a Taoist priest from Yunnan-Guizhou Plateau to Shaolin Temple, where the priest abandoned him. He grew up at Shaolin. Encouraged by the Abbot, he accomplished many things from Kung Fu and meditation to poetry and living in the mountains. His life and search for identity are part of story of Into the Shaolin.
These Shaolin residents and others, have unique stories to tell about their lives at Shaolin. They relate what it means to them, the conflicts, struggles and who they are now. These compelling, interweaving stories reveal much about contemporary life today at Shaolin Temple. Set against the pallet of culture and history of Shaolin Temple they paint a vivid picture few have seen.
The purpose of “Documentary Directing and Storytelling,” is to offer a learning experience and an exploration into directing documentary story projects. Secondly, to offer fundamental and advanced ideas about actuality documentary filmmaking and nonfiction storytelling of all types using film, video, multimedia and other mediums. Finally, this book is a great read for anyone with a strong interest in documentary or nonfiction storytelling. There are many critical reviews of documentary films and the stories they tell from a directing and filmmaking perspective.
The best directors understand the traditions and aesthetics of the medium in which they are working. They also have an understanding of the crafts involved and may have worked at some of those jobs themselves. The focus of “Documentary Directing and Storytelling,” is on directing, but also includes information that experienced directors should know about the process of constructing a documentary story.
“I think it’s inevitable that people will come to find the documentary a more compelling and more important kind of film than fiction. Just as in literature, as the taste has moved from fiction to nonfiction, I think it’s going to happen in film as well. In a way you’re on a serendipitous journey, a journey, which is much more akin to the life experience. When you see somebody on the screen in a documentary, you’re really engaged with a person going through real life experiences. So for that period of time, as you watch the film, you are, in effect, in the shoes of another individual. What a privilege to have that experience.” — Albert Maysles
“If you want to tell the untold stories, if you want to give voice to the voiceless, you’ve got to find a language. Which goes for film as well as prose, for documentary as well as autobiography. Use the wrong language, and you’re dumb and blind.” — Salman Rushdie
“I just decided to make a movie. I had no training, no film school, but I had been to a lot of movies.” —Michael Moore
“I’m a filmmaker. I’m an artist. I’ve chosen to work in history the way someone might choose to work in still life or landscapes.” — Ken Burns
About The Author
James R (Jim) Martin is an Emmy award-winning Director, Writer, and Producer of Film, Television, Video,Multimedia and Digital Media. Professor Martin has taught Film and Video Production at Columbia College Chicago, Directed the Documentary Course at Full Sail University and taught Directing at University of Central Florida. He is the Author of Create Documentary Films, Video and Multimedia, also Actuality Interviewing and Listening and recently Listen Learn Share. He has worked as an independent producer/writer and director of national network documentaries as well as other documentary and fiction productions.
Interest in China for Actuality Documentary Storytelling
Jim Martin in China
Documentary Filmmaker, Professor and Author James R (Jim) Martin has spoken for the second year (2017), at several Chinese Universities about Documentary Filmmaking, Actuality Storytelling and Interviewing. Talks are based on his documentary filmmaking career, writing, and teaching experience as professor in the film production program at Columbia College Chicago and as Director of the documentary course at Full Sail University in Florida.
Jim Martin is the author of Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia and a new book Actuality Interviewing and Listening.
Guangzhou University School of Art and Design
Actuality Interview and Listening covers how to conduct successful interviews for nonfiction storytelling, actuality documentaries and other disciplines using listening techniques and other methods.
Now in its third edition, Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia, is an in-depth manual and guide to every aspect of documentary and nonfiction production.
China Communications University, Beijing
Beijing Film Academy Digital Media, Qingdao, China
[amazon_image id=”0982702361″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Actuality Interviewing and Listening: How to conduct successful interviews for nonfiction storytelling, actuality documentaries and other disciplines … (Documentary and Nonfiction Storytelling)[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”B006P4V71Q” link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos, and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702388″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Listen Learn Share: How & Why Listening, Learning and Sharing can Transform Your Life Experience In Practical Ways[/amazon_image]
Actuality Interviewing and Listening Audio Interview
There are times when conducting a long interview on video may not be necessary. A short interview asking one or two questions to establish the person is shot on video. The balance of the interview might be done with audio only using a recorder like the Zoom H1 or an iPhone App. This audio only part of the interview is used voice over shots of the interviewees doing what they are talking about, archival photographs or scenes related to what’s being discussed.
Make sure the audio levels and quality match what was recorded on video. Use the same microphone if possible. Some filtering or modifications may be needed in post production to match the audio recorded on video.
A film or video documentary usually has two primary components: action and interviews. Of course music and effects also play a role in telling the nonfiction story. But interviewing takes the place of dialog in a fiction film, so it serves the same function in a medium that relies on action to keep an audience engaged.
Actuality Interviewing and Listening techniques allow the subject or subjects of a documentary or nonfiction film to tell their own story in a first person narration. A third person voice over narrator may not be needed. Actuality Interviewing is a form of conducting interviews that relies heavily on the interviewer’s ability to truly listen to the interviewees and to know when to ask the right question. Communication occurs on more levels than what is spoken.
Many people think that they are listening to another person or listening to a piece of music, while they are also thinking about a conversation they had earlier that day or what they are going to say next. Listening requires more than basic attention to someone speaking.
Actuality Interviewing and Listening explores the connection between conducting an interview and listening on all levels. Anyone who conducts interviews or gives interviews, for any reason, will benefit from reading this book.
Opening Morning at 22nd Annual China Documentary Academic Conference in Shenzhen, China – November 2016
It is 14,120 Kilometers (8,774 miles) from Orlando, Florida to Shenzhen, China. Despite the distance and travel time it was an honor and great experience to be at the conference. I was invited to attend by The China Documentary Academic Association (CDAA) to speak about documentary storytelling at the Twenty-second Annual Chinese Documentary Conference held in Shenzhen. While I was in China I was invited to speak at Beijing Normal University and Beijing Film Academy.
Chinese Documentary Classics 2016
My talk was focused on Actuality Documentary Storytelling Techniques, a method of documentary storytelling based on traditional documentary concepts and nonjudgmental recording of events and interviews to create a narrative structure with little or no use of third-party narration.
Presentation and Talk by Jim Martin on Actuality Documentary Storytelling
Documentary films in China seem to have evolved with strong third-party narration components. With third-party narration, a voice over narrator explains the action to the viewer. With Actuality Documentary, there is usually no voice over narrator. The subject tells the story, visually and with first person interviews, both on-screen and at times voice over to narrate action on the screen. This may sound fairly straight forward but the approach demands a degree of mindfulness, awareness and listening to go beyond subjective reactions.
Giving presentation with the help of Interpreter.
I have used actuality documentary storytelling concepts for my own documentaries. I also have taught and wrote about these ideas in a book titled “Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia,” being translated into Chinese. There appears to be a strong interest and growing tradition of documentary storytelling in China.
One of the people greeting at Shenzhen Airport
After thirty hours of flying time it was a pleasure to be greeted at Shenzhen airport by a group of volunteers, one holding up a sign, for the conference, with my name on it. The people I met in Shenzhen and later in Beijing were cordial, friendly and sincere including the sponsors of the conference who welcomed me when I finally reached the hotel at midnight.
I enjoyed meeting all the participants and volunteers I met in the next few days. I felt right at home. My hosts at the conference in Shenzhen were supportive and caring in every way possible. Hotel and dining accommodations were excellent. This area of China is known for it excellent food and favorite Chinese soups.
Dr Hongyun Sun, Assoc. Professor, Beijing Film Academy and Huiqing Niu, Assoc. Professor of Communication University of China
At the conference I took part in a panel discussion about the state of the art of documentary in China and was a presenter in the Documentary Filmmaker Awards Ceremony at a major TV Network facility in Shenzhen honoring Chinese Documentary Filmmakers.
Presenting Awards to Documentary Filmmakers.
One thing that occurred to me during the conference is that this event could have happened somewhere in the US; a film festival and/or conference with enthusiastic people involved in every way. The energy was similar. I enjoyed meeting fellow documentary storytellers and other people at the conference. I learned that there is a strong documentary film community and interest in making documentary films. There is a similar type of human personal energy in China and the United States that I experienced on my first trip to China and two of its largest cities, Beijing in the northeast and Shenzhen in the Southeast.
Host of Award Ceremony and Jim Martin
As the only American documentary filmmaker participating in the conference I felt privileged to be there. During the panel discussion about documentary filmmaking, questions and answers from the panel were thought-provoking and interesting. It appears documentary filmmakers worldwide share many of the concerns and issues we discussed.
The cities of Shenzhen and Beijing are regionally as different as New York City and Orlando, Florida. While Orlando’s sister city in China is Guilin, a three-hour bullet-train ride Northwest, Shenzhen and Orlando share some similarities aside from population, possibly a relative issue. Metro Orlando comes in at around 2.5 million since Shenzhen metro area is much larger, about 18 million. Still both are large cities built up in recent times. Shenzhen has a manufacturing and high-tech base, with a large young population.
Beijing is a huge city of 20,000,000 people. After meeting students at the universities, I spent time seeing a little of Beijing. With the help of Dou Sun, a grad student studying Film Archiving, I saw some special places in the city including Temple of Heaven Park, Forbidden City and park overlooking it, Panjiayuan Market, the film production area in the city and other places. I got to ride on the Beijing subway, it was efficient and very clean. I also had some very good food at a few typical Chinese restaurants, including a noodle shop and a hot-pot restaurant. The Chinese have good reason to love their food!
Card players and bystanders Temple of Heaven Park, Beijing
One of my favorite places was Temple of Heaven Park on a clear day, where people were doing everything from exercising and Tai Chi to playing cards along the railing of a very long porch or veranda. It’s great when a historic site is also a contemporary gathering place for people. I would love to do a short documentary about this park and the people there.
In Beijing I met students who were studying film, and making documentary films of
Talk at Beijing Normal University
their own. The students were enthusiastic and passionate about their work just as students are in the US. Doing the talk for Beijing students made me feel like I was back in a classroom in the US. Most of the students in the classes were also studying English so I did not need an interpreter. Also, as I did in Shenzhen, I added Chinese subtitles and graphics wherever possible. Afterward many students asked me questions about documentaries they were making.
There are plenty of movie theaters these days in China. The cinema is alive and well and people go to the movies. I saw and excellent film by Chinese Director, Feng Xiaogang titled, I Am Not Madame Bovary. It was a satirical story presented in a classic Chinese cinema format but with some experimentation about the shape of the cinema frame. Much of the film was presented in a circular mat.
Student Journalist Jean on right.
A first year journalism student, interested in documentary and the idea of actuality storytelling requested an interview. She was assigned to write an essay for a journal by the course she was taking. We did the interview at a local coffee and tea house near the campus in the University district. I enjoyed some ginger tea and the company.
China is a large country with many provinces and cities. The culture and terrain in China varies as much as it does in Texas and Maine, or Florida and Washington State. The two major cities I visited, Shenzhen and Beijing each have their own culture and traditions. The US and China both share ethnic diversity. The people of China include many ethnic histories over the centuries. I am grateful for the opportunity to spend time visiting China meeting some of its people. I look forward to future visits.
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702361″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Actuality Interviewing and Listening: How to conduct successful interviews for nonfiction storytelling, actuality documentaries and other disciplines … (Documentary and Nonfiction Storytelling)[/amazon_image]
Just when you thought you knew everything about the Beatles along comes Ron Howard with a new traditional documentary film focusing on the Beatles in the beginning, getting underway, then moving on to the years of touring the world, reaching crowds so large they needed super big venues like Shea Stadium housing 50,000 fans at a time on some occasions.
Eight Days A Week asks why, and looks at how the Beatles became such a huge sensation and success. Many possibilities are explored using actual footage of the young Beatles, combined with performance, studio sessions, film clips with behind the scenes from Help, Hard Days Night, and coverage of events, as the Beatles phenomenon grows. Some interviews appear to have been recorded back in the sixties and pulled from archival sources, although there are also good contemporary interviews in the film with Paul McCartney, Ringo Star and others.
Ron Howard as director of Eight Days A Week created a well made traditional compilation documentary built with restored archival footage, paced and edited to keep a an audience occupied and entertained. He allows the good-natured personalities of the young musicians known as the Beatles to emerge during the film. They are band members and friends. It becomes clear that part of the success of the Beatles is their enthusiasm and passion for their music. They love what they do, but do not take themselves too seriously. Contrary to how it may have seemed when they became famous they had put in time slogging away in England and Germany learning performance and writing songs. Brian Epstein’s critical role as the first manager of the Beatles is also apparent in the documentary. George Martin’s producing the music is another important part of the success of the group that is highlighted in Eight Days A Week.
One really amazing reality covered in the documentary is the reaction of teenage fans to the Beatles. In particular young girls, who scream, applaud, cry, become ecstatic, overwhelmed and unconscious at the sight of the Beatles. A head shake by John, Paul, Ringo or George can induce rapture in fans from across the world.
It was the early sixties; perhaps these teenage fans needed the joy and happiness the Beatles’ projected in their performances. Their early songs of “boy meets girl” and love have become classics. The unassuming, unpretentious performance of the Beatles is something to appreciate in this well made documentary.
Eight Days A Week is an excellent documentary for anyone, beginning with those who experienced those days, to others who are just discovering the Beatles and their timeless and now classic music. Eight Days A Week is enjoyable and informative. Highly recommend! Great if you can see it in a theater with good audio. The theatrical release includes thirty minutes of coverage from the Shea Stadium performance in 1962. The sound is a lot better than if you were there, since it was originally played through the stadium PA system!
Review by James R (Jim) Martin
Trailer
The Beatles: Eight Days a Week
The Beatles: Eight Days a Week – The Touring Years
Directed by
Ron Howard
Produced by
Brian Grazer Ron Howard Scott Pascucci Nigel Sinclair
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”B01M13O81J” link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Eight Days A Week – The Touring Years (Blu-Ray Deluxe)[/amazon_image]
The best documentaries both inform and entertain. The viewer learns something new and enjoys the experience. Meet The Patels, winner of the audience award at the 2014 Los Angles Film Festival, achieves these goals as it explores the pressure on Indian American families to keep up their culture and traditions like marriage, when dealing with their American assimilated, second generation children.
This documentary is about Indian Americans, but it is also representative of what happens with other ethnic groups that have resettled in North and South America over the years. All ethnic groups coming to the United States have experienced the pressures of assimilation. Second generation children of immigrants grow up in an environment that is much different from the one the parents came from. The children want to fit in and be accepted in the new culture. Families want their children to marry members of the same ethic or religions group for many reasons. When the children assimilate into the new culture they develop different priorities. Going back to the country of origin to find a mate is difficult as this person may be more compatible with the parents than the child from a cultural standpoint.
Ravi V Patel is both the focus and co-director, with his sister Geeta V. Patel, of the documentary Meet The Patels. Ravi and Geeta’s parents are unhappy that both children, pushing toward thirty years old, have no prospects or plans for marriage. The story evolves around this issue. The father came to the US in the late 1940’s, from the Gujarat area of India, Later he took a trip back to India to marry and bring his new wife back to the US, where Ravi and Getta were both born. It was a traditional arranged marriage. His wife also belonged to the Patel clan, which is considered a caste in India. Patel’s try to marry other Patel’s and there are, according to the parents, many different types of Patels. The documentary looks into “Patel World” in an often-humorous insider fashion.
Ravi works as an actor and Geeta is a filmmaker. They are both typical “Twenty-something” Americans, but of Indian heritage. They do not necessarily want to follow the traditional arranged marriage route. They love their parents and family and would like to please them. After Ravi breaks his two-year relationship with a non-Indian girl, a relationship he kept secret from his parents, he decides, mostly to please his parents, to try their methods for finding a bride. The documentary centers on this process and the methods employed in the search. This includes a family trip to India. The Indian tradition of arranged marriages and finding a marriage partner is not like the American dating style.
Indian families, the Patel’s in particular, have developed a unique international search engine of sorts to help a form of matchmaking that may work better in some ways than many online dating services. In particular, the use of bio-data exchanges. These are basically resumes with compatibility comments and recommendations from family.
Meet the Patels is an unpretentious, first person documentary that is well paced using some animation to fill in any gaps in the narrative. Some scenes may not win awards for cinematography, but the spontaneous feel of the camera work does make you feel like you are there. Editing is good. The story is engaging and one you will remember. This is a documentary well worth seeing from many standpoints. Whatever ethnic group you belong to you may find aspects of Meet The Patels familiar.
[amazon_image id=”B015XC8BT6″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Meet the Patels[/amazon_image]
Books by James R Martin
[amazon_image id=”0982702361″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Actuality Interviewing and Listening: How to conduct successful interviews for nonfiction storytelling, actuality documentaries and other disciplines … (Documentary and Nonfiction Storytelling)[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”B0799P7HNJ” link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Listen Learn Share: How & Why Listening, Learning and Sharing can Transform Your Life Experience In Practical Ways[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
Where To Invade Next is a documentary you won’t forget once you see it. With humor and insight Michael Moore again provides us with food for thought, literally in one instance and figuratively in other ways. This is an important next documentary by Michael Moore after SICKO made about six years ago. This time though Michael Moore takes on a mission, apparently sanctioned by top Pentagon military experts, to invade other countries, win a war and bring back important ideas.
Where To Invade Next is a documentary everyone, especially Americans, should see and think about. It is fast paced, well-edited and explores issues that are topical and great importance for the survival of the United States and perhaps some other countries as well. Michael Moore is at his peak in actuality storytelling with humor and seriousness when necessary. Where To Invade Next doesn’t say other countries are perfect or better than the USA. It just goes after their best ideas and asks the question why not try these ideas in the USA. Why can’t these concepts work in the USA?
Many issues and ideas are explored in Italy, France, Finland, Slovenia (not Slovakia), Germany, Portugal, Norway, Tunisia, and Iceland. These ideas and issues are compared to what is done in the United States. What is revealed is shocking and mind altering. It becomes crystal clear that somehow the people of the United States, the richest, most powerful country in the world, are missing the boat when it comes to taking care of its citizens on many fronts.
TRAILER
Since Franklin Roosevelt rescued this country from pure capitalism and the depression era, with social reforms, there has been a concerted effort by far right capitalists (the same ones that wrecked the stock market and the country in the late 1920’s and 1930’s) and others, to stop any type of social progress in the United States. They have succeeded in many ways, time and time again, to this day. Where To Invade Nextreminds us that social, government enacted legislation benefits all classes of people. These benefits and reforms not only work, they often end up costing tax payers less and helping all people lead a happier, more secure life.
Where To Invade Next is a not too subtle reminder of what the middle and working class people of the United States have been deprived of while many European countries and others have moved ahead with progressive notions on health care, education, equal rights for women, workers rights, drug abuse, prison reform, and family planning. In addition how other countries have dealt with major past problems in their cultures so that they can move on and not repeat the same mistakes. But these types of reforms only happen when citizens demand it by protesting and voting for candidates or parties that advocate basic social amenities for all people.
In typical Michael Moore style he interviews people and visually shows how they live and how their approach to various social solutions work. Michael Moore turns the old Duck Soup line around and asks, …are you going to believe what you see or what the propaganda machine in the US in telling you?Where To Invade Next asks why many other countries have free college education, nutritious food in schools, do not arrest people for drug use, have prison systems that rehabilitate, encourage people to vote, have successful family planning, women’s rights and a basic bill of rights for working, middle-class people.
One interesting fact, among the many, that Where To Invade Next brings to light, is the fact that many of these ideas and concepts actually came from the United States! But they were, hidden, killed and squashed before they could benefit anyone. One concept is as old as our constitution.
While it would be interesting to see a documentary about how all these good ideas got lost in the USA, Michael Moore takes a much more proactive stance showing how these now “alien” ideas actually work. Where To Invade Next brings these ideas back home and suggests we take another look at them.
Where to Invade Next should be seen by every man, woman and child in the United States, as soon as possible. It is a documentary that explores actuality, not the false mantra of “me first” used to manipulate Americans.
DVD AMAZON
[amazon_image id=”B01D0D3P5U” link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Where To Invade Next[/amazon_image]
Review by James R (Jim) Martin, Documentary Filmmaker and Author of:
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702388″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Listen Learn Share: How & Why Listening, Learning and Sharing can Transform Your Life Experience In Practical Ways[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702361″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Actuality Interviewing and Listening: How to conduct successful interviews for nonfiction storytelling, actuality documentaries and other disciplines … (Documentary and Nonfiction Storytelling)[/amazon_image]
Vivian Maier was born on February 1, 1926 in New York City. Around the age of 25 or 26 she started taking photographs, about 100,000 or more pictures by the time she died on April 21, 2009, ninety-nine percent of which she never showed anyone. She worked as a Nanny and/or Housekeeper most of her life using her spare time to photograph in New York City, Chicago, a village in France, and on an eight-month world tour accompanied by her trusted twin-lens Rollie camera hanging from her neck. Her work was discovered two years before she died but she was unaware of it. It included documentary style photography, 8mm film and audio recordings.
Two years before she died, on April 21, 2009 in Chicago, storage lockers where she stored her work and other things were sold at auction for non-payment of the monthly fees. John Maloof bought boxes of negatives and went on to buy more boxes of negatives, undeveloped rolls of film, 8mm and 16mm movie film from other bidders later on. He discovered the inspired work of Vivian Maier and ultimately brought her photography to public attention.
Finding Vivian Maier Documentary. See trailer below.
There are now two documentary films about Vivian Maier. 1)The Vivian Maier Mystery, fifty-three minutes, released in 2013 by BBC. 2) Oscar Nominated, Finding Vivian Maier, 84 minutes, released in 2013/14 by Sundance Selects, directed by John Maoof and Charlie Siskel.
Vivian Maier Mystery Documentary
In addition there are several books, two of which are: Vivian Maier – Street Photographer, published by powerHouse Books and edited by John Maloof. The second titled Vivian Maier: A PhotographerFound also by John Maloof. Vivian Maier – Street Photographer is a great representative collection and introduction to Maier’s work. The book allows you to see through her eyes and get to know her through her work with no distractions. Maier has a well-developed sense of composition, contrast and focus. With the twin-lens reflex camera hanging from her neck she looked down into the view finder and shot from about waist-high most of the time. While she did shoot many self-portraits, she took herself out of the rest of what she shot. It seems like most of the time the subjects are not aware of her being there. She photographed everywhere from rough urban slums to elite suburban settings where she worked. She shot children, groups of people, portraits, street scenes and events with a journalist’s eye. Much of her work would have looked at home in Life Magazine of the 1950’s and 1960’s.
Vivian Maier had an eye for the ironic juxtaposition of people and their environment. For example a small boy standing on a wood frame looking into a very large box on a city sidewalk or a Father holding up his son’s leg to look at his shoe as the boy hangs on to him for balance looking uncomfortable. She also likes the light, texture and patterns seen in urban environments. Her portraits show something deeper than the faces of her subjects. Somehow she captures an intimate moment when someone’s personality pops up for a second. Her work demonstrates sensitivity to social and cultural aspects of what she shoots.
The Vivian Maier Mystery Documentary and Finding Vivian Maier Documentary, each have something to offer anyone trying to discover who this talented photographic artist is and how she got that way.
At first Vivian Maier does appear to be something of a mystery, a mystery she surrounded herself with. Both documentaries, through interviews with the grown up children and clients she worked for, mention how little they really knew about her and how secretive she was. She would not discuss her family or anything personal usually. However, on one of the tapes she made interviewing a woman about her meeting Rudolf Valentino, Vivian appears to do more talking than the interviewees including meeting she had with celebrities and her impressions of certain places she visited or lived in.
The Finding Vivian Maier documentary is longer and more in-depth in certain areas than The Vivian Maier Mystery because it has John Maloof interviews and access to his huge collection of photographs, negatives, and film footage that Vivian Maier shot. The Vivian Maier Mystery spends a bit more time looking into Ms Maier’s time in France and tracing her family. It also interviews collectors other than John Maloof.
There is a lot of controversy surrounding Vivian Maier and her estate that consists only of the copyright ownership of her work. She died with no known relatives except for a couple of second cousins in France. Maloof was able to get a release to publish and print the photographs from one of the cousins. Another collector, Jeffrey Goldstein, with 17,500 photographs also believed he had cleared rights until Cook County in Illinois, in charge of Maier’s estate, sent letters out stating that no one had clear rights to distribute the work. Cook County was searching for Vivian Maier’s brother who no one had seen, who disappeared scores of years ago and was presumed dead. Although Maloof had gotten permission from a living relative, he had not cleared it through probate court, so his permission deemed was not legal. Articles on this subject at http://www.vivianmaierprints.com/vivian-maier-articles.html
Prices for prints of Vivian Maier’s work are still available and costly. Jeffery Goldstein sold his collection to a gallery in Canada. Other galleries and Maloof are still selling prints. Vivian Maier did not print much of her work. She had the film developed and saved the negatives. So prints of her work have a third-party involved. Dark room printing of photographs is part of the photographer’s art. The good news is that her composition and framing were pretty specific so printers may be able to focus on contrast and exposure issues.
Aside from all the controversy Vivian Maier is an important American photographer and artist. The documentaries and books show her amazing life and work. The mysterious part is why she didn’t seek some sort of show or outlet for her work. It comes to light in reading the books and looking at the documentaries that at certain times she did try to show her work. For example she tried to negotiate a deal with a printer in France to make postcards from her pictures. Still she was secretive and didn’t push to show her work to anyone.
It is possible that Vivian Maier fancied herself as some sort of undercover photographer at certain times. She took on the role, and point-of-view of a photojournalist at times. She did interviews with people on her portable recorder on topical subjects like elections. She took pictures of celebrities and politicians. All her work is documentary in some form. Something in her personality prevented her from seeking employment as a photographer or seeking a wide audience for her work. If the postcards had been printed and sold, she would still be basically anonymous. Employers, their children and one or two friends all described Vivian as opinionated and at times argumentative or short-tempered. Although her work shows clearly that she had a sense of humor and progressive social tendencies.
Hopefully, when all the legal maneuvering is finished a traveling show of Vivian Maier’s work can be put together so that the world can see her work in person.
Review by James R Martin – Documentary Filmmaker, Author – Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia
Trailer Finding Vivian Maier
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
The PBS – American Experience: Walt Disney documentary provides an uncensored, well researched, exploration of Walt Disney, the man, his work, and his passion for achieving goals. The 221 minute documentary looks into Walt Disney’s contributions to the art of film, his strengths and weaknesses. The film examines Disney’s great insight into American culture and at other times his opaque insensitivity to historical, political and social issues facing Americans. Walt Disney was an artist and an entrepreneur, greatly aided in his goals by Roy Disney, his brother, who complemented Walt’s apparent obsessive personality with practical nuance.
American Experience: Walt Disney informs and entertains. It is a great biography of Disney and the development of animated feature films. From a historical filmmaking point of view the documentary is a treasure trove of information, enhanced by the unlimited access given American Experience, to the Disney historical archives. There are photographs, and documentary footage of Walt Disney though out his life. Disney seemed to have someone there taking pictures or shooting activities all the time. The film’s narrative structure is greatly enhanced by this visual actuality of events. Interviews with people who knew Walt Disney also help tell the story. There is a linear chronology of Walt Disney’s life contrasted with events and life around him. Clips from classic Disney films are included throughout the documentary.
Walt Disney’s early attempts at creating short cartoons for distribution ultimately lead to the creation of Mickey Mouse, demonstrating Disney’s innovation including the first use of audio for an animated short. These early scenes in the documentary may be of particular interest to aspiring filmmakers as well as Disney fans.
One of the most interesting aspects of the documentary is Walt Disney’s idea to create a feature-length animated film that was Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. Because of Disney’s determination to create a perfect, artistic film that transcended the notion that animation was only for cartoons, Snow White took five years to make and greatly exceeded its original budget. When it was finally released it was a huge national and international success. It achieved all that Disney intended, except winning an Oscar for Best Film. It did win an Oscar for innovation which didn’t really meet Disney’s expectations.
American Experience: Walt Disneyis set up in two parts that total four hours. It is well-edited and does not lag or get redundant. In fact there seems to be a pick-up of pace in the last hour to cover Disney Land creation, it’s success, the beginnings of Epcot, Disney World in Florida and Walt’s untimely death at age 65 from Lung Cancer. This is a biographical film about Walt Disney; however, it might have included more about his brother and alter ego Roy Disney. This is not to say Roy’s important role in Walt Disney’s life is ignored. It’s that Roy seems to always be in the shadows making things happen and trying to rein in his brother. It would have been interesting to know more about Roy and how he accomplished these things. Perhaps Roy Disney is another story.
The documentary does not gloss over Walt Disney’s problems with his employees, unions, his obsession with communists everywhere, or his insensitivity to minorities and racial stereotypes like those seen in Song of the South and other Disney films, television programs and other endeavors. In many ways it seems from watching the documentary that Walt Disney mirrored the cultural biases of his generation.
American Experience: Walt Disney does what an excellent biographical documentary should do. It explores reality, in this case the life of Walt Disney, with the goal of understanding who he was as a person and what he created during his lifetime. The successes, the failures and personality traits of a creative human being in the context of the world they lived in.
American Experience: Walt Disney aired on PBS in mid September 2015. It is available on Apple TV and on DVD from PBS and Amazon.
Review by James R (Jim) Martin – Documentary Filmmaker and Author
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
Trailer
DVD
[amazon_image id=”B00YJDHA7U” link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]American Experience: Walt Disney[/amazon_image]
“…the Constitution, baseball and jazz music. They’re the three most beautiful things Americans have ever created.” – Gerald Early
Jazz is one of Ken Burns’ best documentary films. Like most of his work the series transcends being solely a factual historical record. Burns puts the facts into historical and social context. Jazz, the documentary, fits the evolution of Jazz music in with American culture, Black History, people and politics of the United States. The history of Jazz, it turns out, is born out of circumstances uniquely American, to a large extent, in New Orleans of the 1890’s. Jazz —“It is a creation of the African-American community there, but incorporates all kind of music heard in the streets of what was the country’s most cosmopolitan city.” Jazz soon moves out of New Orleans and becomes a national passion. This documentary will either introduce you to Jazz or increase your appreciation and enjoyment of this music.
Documentary films come in many forms, evolving from the simple recording and editing of events to hybrid styles that incorporate fictional recreations of events. Ken Burn’s documentaries do not recreate events using actors. Instead he incorporates, often meticulously restored or discovered, archival photographs, film and documents, to create a narrative structure.
Ken Burns has created his own documentary niche. His forte is historical documentaries that delve into American culture and life since the Civil War. According to Erik Barnouw, in History of Non-fiction Film, Ken Burns is the only Documentary Filmmaker ever invited to be a member of the Society of American Historians. “Burns was the first ever elected without having written a book. Recognition of documentary as a medium for the writing of history.” –Barnouw
Wynton Marsalis
In the opening minutes of Episode One, musician Wynton Marsalis states, “Jazz music objectifies America. It’s an art form that can give us a painless way of understanding ourselves. The real power of Jazz, the innovation of jazz, is that a group of people can come together and create art, improvised art and can negotiate their agendas with each other, and that negotiation is the art.” Other interviews or commentary throughout the documentary by, Albert Murray, Gary Giddens, Stanley Crouch, Gerald Early and others give ongoing narration.
The story begins by introducing the environment, politics and culture of the day, then exploring how it all got that way. Individual artists are highlighted against the backdrop of their world. There are dozens of parallel themes that weave their way though this documentary. One theme, that also exists in other documentaries, like Civil War and Baseball by Burns, is the ongoing, vitriolic backdrop of race relations and racism in America. The documentary does not ignore racial segregation and the way black musicians were treated in America.
Another theme is the history of the country and the world to some extent. The major theme, of course, is exploring Jazz music; although some critics’ feel the documentary isn’t inclusive enough of all who contributed. Despite this possibility, Jazz does a great job introducing those interested in music to the subject and wetting appetites for more. Documentary films are visual and always subject to holding the viewer’s attention. Books can be read at any pace. Unlike a history book, of unlimited length and verbose explanations, a documentary film must be succinct, keep pace and fit into a time frame from which most people will view it. Music historians, experts and professors would do well to consider this as a documentary film intended for all audiences, not a history book. Even nineteen hours is not enough to cover the history of Jazz completely.
Louis Armstrong
Film and video are, primarily, a visual mediums. More recently sound has become a more equal partner in telling the story in film and video. However, the medium is still dominated by the visual part of the presentation. A contemporary viewer/listener can see and hear at the same time, absorb, understand and appreciate the visual/audio gestalt. As tempting as it might be, filmmakers do not have the luxury, in a documentary about music, to hold a picture or a blank frame, for the music to play for three minutes, so the composition can be listened to exclusively.
Ken Burns’ documentaries are notoriously long. At ten episodes, the total running time for Jazz is about 19 hours. But each of the ten episodes moves along at a good pace. Listening to Jazz, hearing Jazz artists and others talk about Jazz is not difficult. Perhaps because the music is so vibrant, the documentary often feels like a music video with actuality footage. There’s a lot to be learned here not only about Jazz but also about the America it evolved in and in-turn helped shape.
Jazz was aired on PBS in the year 2000. It reportedly cost $13,000,000 to make. That’s an average of $1,300,000 per, roughly ninety minute to two-hour, episode. In true Ken Burns, and traditional documentary style, there are no actors hired to recreate historic events. Historic archival photographs, film or video footage, interviews and voice-over narration by interviewees, historians and others are the basis for the story. It is well-edited and paced. You probably won’t “binge watch” all nineteen hours and that’s good, because there is a lot to enjoy, and think about. As Ken Burns has said, “meaning accrues in duration.” So take your time, enjoy and learn.
When Ken Burns said, “meaning accrues in duration,” he was originally referring to an editing style that usually takes its time. In the case of Jazz the editing pace is driven by the music, (497 pieces of music) which makes things feel like they are moving faster. There are times when it does seem the theme is digressing a bit too much into the context side of the story of Jazz, but not very often. Jazz both entertains and informs on many levels. The documentary offers a wonderful combination of music, and story. In the words of Ken Burns, “[Jazz] is the soundtrack of America.”
Ken Burns reflecting about his work in The Making of Jazz, a special short documentary on the first episode disc, mentions that he has spent a total 16 years of his life working on three films; Civil War, Baseball and Jazz. He mentions a quote by Gerald Early, “…when they study our civilization, two thousand years from now, there will only be three things that Americans will be known for: the Constitution, Baseball and Jazz music. They’re the three most beautiful things Americans have ever created.”
“And JAZZ is also a story about race and race relations and prejudice, about minstrelsy and Jim Crow, lynching’s and civil rights. JAZZ explores the uniquely American paradox that our greatest art form was created by those who have had the peculiar experience of being unfree in our supposedly free land. African-Americans in general, and black jazz musicians in particular, carry a complicated message to the rest of us, a genetic memory of our great promise and our great failing, and the music they created and then generously shared with the rest of the world negotiates and reconciles the contradictions many of us would rather ignore. Embedded in the music, in its riveting biographies and soaring artistic achievement, can be found our oft-neglected conscience, a message of hope and transcendence, of affirmation in the face of adversity, unequaled in the unfolding drama and parade we call American history. “ — Ken Burns
Trailer
Episodes
Episode One, 90 minutes, entitled Gumbo sets the stage for the birth of Jazz and traces the roots, music and culture that nurtured it in New Orleans. Some would dispute the notion that New Orleans was the exclusive “birthplace” of Jazz but the documentary makes a good case for New Orleans as the epicenter for the origins of Jazz. Wynton Marsalis and others add their personal, often profound, observations about Jazz including its evolution and artists. Even if you never watch the other nine episodes you will have a better understanding and feel for the roots of this American music form after watching this episode. It’s likely, however, that you will want to watch the rest of the story, especially, if you have a love of music and/or American history.
Episode Two, 120 minutes, entitled The Gift, captures the musical magic of this era and begins around the time of Prohibition, and a booming stock market. It introduces Louis Armstrong and Duke Ellington as well as Jazz development in Chicago and New York cities. Louis Armstrong’s life and his “gift” are explored. James Reiss Europe’s contribution to marching bands and Jazz music, set against the backdrop of WW1 and the African-American troops fighting in France. Duke Ellington’s Blessed beginnings in Washington DC. All of this at a time when Jim Crow practices and the Klu Klux Klan threatened minorities. This was a time when Jazz music was said to threaten the morals of young people dancing to the sound. By the end of Episode 2, Louis Armstrong brings his genius to Rose Land in NY City and Fletcher Henderson’s Band.
Episode Three, 120 minutes, entitled OurLanguage, Roaring Twenties, Prohibition, Bands and people who contribute to the evolution of Jazz. Bessie Smith and Ethel Waters sing the Blues, Bix Beiderbecke a white Cornet player from the Midwest, plays Jazz, Benny Goodman and Artie Shaw become a part of the scene. Dance bands with all white or black musicians play venues for all audiences in the mostly segregated world of the day. Duke Ellington played for white only audiences at the Cotton Club in New York City and is broadcast on radio all over the country. The Paul Whiteman Band became well-known. But in the end it’s Louis Armstrong’s amazing work that takes center stage. Armstrong along with Earl Hines record “West End Blues,” a truly classical piece of music, featuring Armstrong’s, Blues inspired, improvisational style.
Episode Four, 120 minutes, entitled The True Welcome, goes from the twenties to the stock market crash in 1929, after which some said the Jazz age was over. Up until that time musicians like Louis Armstrong, Duke Ellington, Fats Waller, Fletcher Hendricks, and other had played for small, mainly black audiences. As radio broadcasting of music came in and started to broadcast life performances, first Duke Ellington from the Savoy, Jazz became popular. People started dancing to a form of Jazz called Swing. Ellington ushered in the “Big Band” sound and was soon followed by other bands. Louis Armstrong set the tone for Jazz in the 1930’s when he started doing “skat” singing along with his trumpet playing. His style was known as “Black and Blue.” Chick Webb, a drummer put together a band that played at the Savoy in Harlem. Soon Benny Goodman came along with his band and three-hour Radio Broadcast. This episode covers a range of musicians who made their mark on Jazz. John Hammon, Billy Rose, Art Tatem and Jelly Roll Morton to name a few in this episode. In 1933 Duke Ellington brings his band to Europe playing numbers like Mood Indigo. Europe embraces Ellington and Jazz.
Episode Five, 90 minutes, entitled Swing Pure Pleasure, covers the mid 1930’s, Jazz goes mainstream with white musicians and bands. Benny Goodman, known as the “King of Swing,” Tommy Dorsey, Jimmie Lunceford, Glen Miller and Artie Shaw. Meanwhile Duke Ellington continues to builds in own sound and band. Louis Armstrong starts his band. Billie Holiday begins her career. At the end of this episode four thousand people come to the Savoy Ballroom in Harlem to see “The Music Battle of the Century,” a face off between Goodman and Chick Webb.
Episode Six, 105 minutes, Swing:The Velocity of Celebration, where two amazing Jazz tenor sax musicians emerge. Lester Young with own distinctive sound and Coleman Hawkins with his voice. In Kansas City Count Basie creates his own Jazz sound. Chick Webb, almost reluctantly, introduces Ella Fitzgerald to the world. Billie Holiday sings “Strange Fruit,” expressing her personal pain and indignation of racism in America. Duke Ellington tours Europe weeks before World War II begins.
Episode Seven, 120 minutes, Dedicated to Chaos, covers the Jazz world against the backdrop and chaos of World War Two. A lot is happening in music, from Charlie Parker’s improvisation and original approach on Alto Saxophone to the fact that 30 million Jazz music records were sold in 1940. “Swing” music and dancing were at a peak and big bands would go to war with the country. Louis Armstrong’s band toured the United States. Duke Ellington and his band had their own sound and style. Dizzy Gillespie trumpet is unforgettable. Billie Holiday sings Lady Day, Duke Ellington Orchestra performs his forty-four minute composition at Carnegie Hall with First Lady Elenore Roosevelt in attendance. Dave Brubeck talks about playing piano as a soldier in Europe. But when he returned to the US after the war his integrated band could not stay in the same hotel.
Episode Eight, 120 minutes, Risk, Charlie Parker’s genius is focused on as well as his tragic, short life. Parker and Gillespie invent a new Jazz sound called Bebop as Gillespie’s band tours the country. New artists, bringing new ideas, emerge including Miles Davis, Dave Brubeck, Gerry Mulligan and John Lewis. First International Jazz Festival held in Paris, 1949. Parker records an album called “Parker with Strings.” Bird Land, club named after Charlie “Bird” Parker, opened in New York City. In 1957, Miles Davis’s album, “Birth of the Cool,” made up of recordings from the late 1940’s, was released by Capitol records, establishing Davis and his music to a wide audience.
Episode Nine, 120 minutes, The Adventure, Jazz takes on different styles “the definition of what was Jazz and what was not began to blur.” Matt Glaser, musician states, “ When we talk about music, the reason we use terms that sound vague is not because there is anything vague about music, but because music expresses human experience so specifically, in such specific ways, that when you use language to describe that the words fall short…” In episode nine Charlie Parker’s career is ended by Heroin addiction. Miles Davis records on Prestige label with many well-known artists of the fifties and sixties. Clifford Brown establishes a no drugs life style. Sara Vaughn sings. In 1957 Louis Armstrong sees Little Rock disaster and refused to go on International tour for the State Department. Art Blakey and the Jazz messengers with Horace Silver and Jimmy Smith appear. Billie Holiday and Lester Young perform together. John Coltrane breaks new ground in 1961. Jazz takes an avant guard turn with Ornette Coleman and his quartet.
Episode Ten, 120 minutes, A Masterpiece By Midnight, essentially a wrap up from the 1960’s, of the entire documentary introducing artists and trends up to the year 2000 when JAZZ was aired on PBS. The narrative incorporates domestic and world events with the evolution and emergence of a number of trends in Jazz. Specific artists are also covered from Louis Armstrong’s unexpected hit with “Hello Dolly,” to artists like Max Roach, Charlie Mingus, Abbey Lincoln, Dexter Gordon, Charlie Bird, Duke Ellington, Miles Davis and others. So much has continued to happen to Jazz Music since the year 2000, that it seems time for a sequel in 2016.
LINKS
Amazon Purchase Jazz
[amazon_image id=”B000BITUEI” link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Jazz: A Film By Ken Burns[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”1721679464″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Documentary Directing and Storytelling: How to Direct Documentaries and More![/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702388″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Listen Learn Share: How & Why Listening, Learning and Sharing can Transform Your Life Experience In Practical Ways[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702361″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Actuality Interviewing and Listening: How to conduct successful interviews for nonfiction storytelling, actuality documentaries and other disciplines … (Documentary and Nonfiction Storytelling)[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
“A civilization without insanity, without war, where the able can prosper and honest beings can have rights, and where man is free to rise to greater heights, are the aims of Scientology.” –L. Ron Hubbard
The Going Clear documentary is based on a book written by Lawrence Wright, titled Going Clear: “Scientology, Hollywood and the Prison of Belief.” Scientology objects to the book and the documentary. As recently reported (8.5.2015) by the Guardian: the church, from its Los Angeles HQ, has denounced the film as a “one-sided, bigoted propaganda built on falsehoods” and informed by former members – whom it calls “misfits”.
In April, the church said in a statement: “The Church of Scientology will be entitled to seek the protection of both UK and Irish libel laws in the event that any false or defamatory content in this film is broadcast within these jurisdictions.”
Going Clear is a well-made film. Good editing and use of archival material and interviews. There is a lot of footage of Scientology events and places. Scientology officially calls it “propaganda.” But that label is not appropriate unless it can be shown that the filmmakers are misrepresenting the truth and hiding their true point-of-view (POV). A documentary film is not propaganda simply because you don’t agree with it’s premise or reality. One definition of a propaganda film is that is was made by a government, with a political philosophy or by institutions with missions. Going Clear does not meet these criteria.
Going Clear has a point-of-view that it doesn’t try to hide. All documentaries have a point-of-view. A documentary cannot help but be a subjective exploration of human reality. The fact that you do not agree with the point-of-view of a documentary does not make the documentary propaganda. Going Clear uses first person interviews from many people expressing their experiences. Evidence supporting the filmmaker’s POV is presented and explored.
Watching the documentary Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief brought back memories of a visit I made to East Grinstead in England, where there is a Scientology center.
Scientology Headquarters – East Grinstead
My friends Pam and Henry, talented painters and pottery makers, who I met in Harrogate, Yorkshire, had moved to East Grinstead. We kept in touch and when I came back to England to study film at the London Film School, in the early 1970’s, they invited me to visit them in their new home and studio in East Grinstead, a town in the northeastern corner, West Sussex. Not that it would have mattered to me, had I known, but Saint Hill Manner, in East Grinstead, was also the home of L. Ron Hubbard and the Headquarters for Scientology in Great Britain.
Pam and Henry had become Scientologists. They gave me a tour of the facility and some literature including Hubbard’s Dianetics, and a pamphlet of Axioms. They told me that Scientology was becoming a religion and was looking for recruits to become what sounded to me like ministers or perhaps monitors. I said, I was passionate about studying film but in any event could not afford to join Scientology. They said not to worry about money that “Ron would find a way.” I asked why Scientology was becoming a religion? They said to avoid persecution and get tax-exempt status. I chose to continue to study film.
I read the Dianetics book and other literature; some of it made sense on a practical level. But I never joined Scientology nor have I ever paid the Transcendental Meditation people for a mantra. I think “self-help” is a good thing, but do not like paying someone else to help me “self-help.”
The Going Clear documentary is a pretty straightforward expose style piece that mainly goes after the management of the International Association of Scientology (IAS) and the Church of Scientology. In particular it singles out David Miscovige, a self-appointed protégé of L. Ron Hubbard (LRH) and current Chairman of the Board, as a megalomaniac and serial abuser of staff. Going Clear also questions and explores the not-for-profit, religious status of this Billion-dollar corporation.
David Miscavige, Chairman of the Board
Going Clear begins with a history of L. Ron Hubbard and how he ultimately founded Scientology based on his Dianetics Book. In addition to interviews with Sara Northrupt, Hubbards first wife, the film uses a some interviews, archival photographs, video and a few minor, apparent recreations to tell the story. The film depicts LRH has a prolific author of science fiction, much of which is incorporated into the back-story of Scientology. A number of insiders, like Paul Haggis, Jason Begle and Spanky Taylor, who have left Scientology after long association, paint a grim, behind the scenes, picture and how Miscovige consolidated his power and keeps people in line. They also discuss what amounts to a form of brainwashing they believe is practiced in Scientology.
Going Clear also looks at the auditing process which is the corner-stone of Scientology and the way one becomes “Clear.” Using a device, with two cans that one holds and that are connected to a meter, electrical impulses are monitored during what is called and “audit.” This contraption has been characterized as one-third of a lie detector machine. The person doing the monitoring asks questions and makes copious notes of each session. People who join Scientology pay to go through a long series of audits on what is called a “bridge” to becoming clear and ultimately achieving “Theata” status.
Two celebrities who are well-known Scientologists are focused on in the documentary. They are John Travolta and Tom Cruise. Neither Travolta nor Cruise was interviewed for the Going Clear documentary but there is still plenty of footage of them in the film. Travolta joined Scientology early on in his career. He seems a fairly non-controversial member. Tom Cruise’s story is different, especially during the time he was married to Nicole Kidman. The documentary makes the case that Miscovige interfered in the marriage, secretly, and later overtly, because he believed Kidman, who he labeled in Scientology speak, “a suppressive person,” was pulling Cruise away from Scientology. After Kidman and Cruise divorced, Tom Cruise was back, prominently representing Scientology as a spokesperson.
The Going Clear documentary goes beyond perceived and documented issues it finds with Scientology. By default it brings attention to the tax-exempt status of some institutions that seem more about making money than any kind of not-for-profit mission. It also may ask exactly what constitutes a religion? Is Scientology posing as a religion? Did Scientology harass the IRS into giving it Not-For-Profit, status as a religion, which also gives Scientology certain First Amendment protection. Are there other institutions in the same category? There have been other negative documentaries and book about Scientology. Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief is hard to ignore.
HBO – 120 minutes – Directed by Alex Gibney
Review by Jim Martin, documentary filmmaker, writer, director and author.
Books by James R Martin
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
Making a short documentary isn’t much different from making a long documentary in theory. But in practice it can be a lot more difficult. There are many unique factors involved in a short form documentary or fiction films that need to be considered. For starters it’s easy to make a “long” documentary that will put people to sleep after the first minutes. Making a three-minute or seven-minute documentary presents several issues that involve planning and knowing what you want to do.
Let’s say there’s some great equipment available (we’ll talk more about equipment later) and an event about which you want to make a short documentary. Someone with little experience might think that all they have to do is get a ton of coverage and then edit it down to make their documentary. Just shoot everything that happens. Maybe use a couple of cameras to make sure they get it all. The next day with twenty Terabytes of footage to edit down to seven minutes where do they start? It’s an overwhelming task because there was no plan, no direction, and no concept about what would really be done with all this footage. No preconceived notion of a story or how it would be told.
Shooting twenty Terabytes of coverage of an event, with no particular story concept in mind, is nothing more than shooting archival footage. The event has been documented but that’s where it ends. Is it possible to pull a story of sorts out of all the footage? Sure, but archival in, is archival out. A documentary begins with the goal of telling a story about the event that gives the viewer a subjective interpretation of what happened. While the archival footage, is also subjective in the end, it’s purpose was to simply record the event. It is like C-Span coverage of congress. The coverage is usually from chosen, locked off, camera positions, lens choices and angles. It’s hard to stay engaged watching this type of video.
The place to start with a documentary idea, is with a concept and treatment about the subject for the story. What’s the story? Where do you want to go with this story? Who are the characters in this story? Who is the audience for the story?
Let’s say the event is one that happens once a year in an urban community. It’s been going on for a several years as a charitable event, is well attended and participation is high. People have fun and the competition involved in the event is not taken too seriously or is it? Here’s an example.
For the past eight years there has been a “Doggie Derby” held in Baldwin Park, a moderately upscale community in Orlando, Florida. The concept is to put together a short documentary that in a few minutes gives the festive feel of Doggie Derby Day in Baldwin Park and the people and dogs involved. But we still don’t have a story. This is only an idea.
That’s where the Treatment comes in. A treatment narrative conveys the story line, beginning, middle and end. Also the style and approach to be used in telling story.
A basic treatment lets the director know what the story is about and a basic approach to telling the story. For a short documentary the treatment doesn’t have to be very long. The idea is to pre-visualize how the story will be told and what it will look like on the screen.
There could be a bigger story here but the goal is to keep it short and still give the viewer a real feel for what goes on at the event. The treatment establishes an opening that includes some establishing shots, background if possible, shots of the people and dogs. More footage of the actual dog racing and how the participants, two-legged and four-legged, react to the proceedings. The style of shooting is intimate which means close-ups of people and action. The story starts with establishing shots of the venue, people and action. Once the action is established a short interview with the organizers; “how did the Doggie Derby get started?” Then show more action, dogs racing, people watching and enjoying the event. Interview couples that have entered their dogs and why they do it. Other interviews if possible. Story ends with awards to winners of the last races.
If a longer more in-depth story was required, the treatment could go into more detail about each area. For example while the interview with the organizers goes on, voice over archival footage of earlier year’s events is included. More interviews and questions asked of more people. Interviews with winners and other participants also possible. Vendors who sponsor the Doggie Derby each year would be interviewed. Show and interview volunteers who help set up the venue. Keep track of each race and interview finalist as they progress toward the Grand Champion race.
The outcome of all the races or what people will do or say is not known. But a shooting script to further develop the concept and treatment could be written. This script is more about what the filmmakers will do than what the subjects will do or say. A full shooting script is not always necessary or practical. It would be great if earlier years were attended or the organizers talked to in advance so that there is an idea of what may be happening. A shooting script for a documentary is in some ways a “wish-list” of what is needed to tell a story. But documentaries are exploratory; things may be very different from what is expected. The pre-production, concept, treatment and a shooting script are a way to get the director out there with some ideas about how to tell the story, whatever it turns out to be.
After the shooting is finished and coverage logged and reviewed, an editing script should be written so new information and actual footage may be molded into a story that has a beginning, middle and end. Editing can go ahead without an absolute fixed length for the story. Edit for story and pace not time. Trying to stretch footage to get to a certain length will be obvious and the quickest way to lose an audience. Of course some time constraints may exist, usually it’s a matter of tightening up and not adding scenes. Be ready to throw your favorite shot under the bus if it doesn’t add to the story.
The Doggie Derby Day story was envisioned a few days before the actual event. It was based on the director having attended the Doggie Derby in earlier years. The idea was to spontaneously tell a simple story that gave a feel for the event as described above. This was also a time to test out some lightweight equipment for use in fluid documentary situations using very small crews.
In this case the “crew” was a Director/camera operator, Production Assistant/recorder/microphone holder and a second camera operator, primarily for action and production stills, and some video.
EQUIPMENT
In a earlier post theCanon 7D Mark II and Atomos Ninja Starwere reviewed for their potential use in a documentary situation. Doggie Derby Day provided a multifaceted test for the equipment including portability, quality, ease of use and practical field-testing. In addition a Zoom H1 was used as a microphone/recorder to work double system.
The ZOOM H1 was hand-held most of the time by an assistant. It was also used attached to a heavy-duty photography “L” and flash shoe mount bracket that also held the 7D Mark II. The Ninja Star was attached to the 7D hot shoe. This rig was set up to test one-person operation. A shoulder mount was available but not tested this time around. A tripod was available but not very practical for one person at this type of event (Think doggie POV using a tripod?). A Canon 6D was used by a second camera operator who shot production stills, action stills and supporting video.
The Canon 7D Mark II with the Ninja Star mounted on the hot shoe is lightweight. Attaching an “L” bracket to the camera offered two-handed shooting, and one-handed shooting using either hand. The Zoom H1, microphone/recorder is very light and easily mounted to one of the shoes on the bracket. An alternative might be the Zoom H5 with a shotgun microphone. A wireless lavaliere microphone could also be used with either the Zoom H1 or H5 as there is an input for an external microphone on both, but only the H5 has XLR inputs.
An intimate feel was desired for the Doggie Derby Day documentary. Using a zoom lens was possible and the Canon 28mm to 135mm F3.5 – 5.5 was used for a few shots, but the bulk of the shooting was done with the Canon EFS 24mm F.2.8 STM with its tiny lens hood. The EF-S Mount Lens is APS-C matching the 7D Mark II format (38mm – Equivalent for 35mm full frame) . This small prime lens performed perfectly for this situation. It focuses quickly and quietly utilizing the camera’s Movie Servo AF mode. This lens allows close-ups to be shot without distortion and wide shots as well. No zooming of the lens all the time to change focal length. Instead the camera is moved closer or farther from the subject (Isn’t that a novel idea?). The prime lens has sharpness and is lightweight.
Setting up the Canon 7D Mark II to work with Atomos Ninja Star is not difficult but certain guidelines must be followed for settings in the camera’s Menu. Please see https://www.jrmartinmedia.com/director/canon-7d-mark-ii-and-ninja-star/ for set up instructions. This set up, apparently by default, provided “proxy” H.264 .mov files including picture and sound in the camera, the same footage that was being recorded in HQ4.22, Pro Res on the Ninja Star. To avoid recording to the camera memory, push the record button on the Ninja Star instead of using the camera trigger. The footage will only record to the Ninja Star.
Zoom H1 and Ninja Star both mounted on “L” bracket leaves hot shoe free. Also may work well with LED viewfinder attachment and shoulder mount.
The 7D Mark II has two memory cards that can be set so that the camera automatically switches to the second card when the first is full. To prevent interruption of shooting, change out the CF card in the camera when it is 90% full and set the camera to switch to the second card when the first is full. In a pinch you could continue shooting using the second card. The camera will not record if the memory cards in the camera are full.
Post production and editing for a short documentary film depends on how well the pre-production and production went. After importing the footage into an editing program, the first step is to log and review all the footage. In the case of Doggie Derby Day there were two types of footage plus photographs to import into Final Cut Pro. All of the footage recorded on the Ninja Star was Pro Res HQ 4.22. This imports in to Final Cut natively, since Pro Res is what Final Cut edits with. Footage recorded to the Canon 7D Mark II was H.264, but Final Cut Pro has an optimization setting that upgrades the H.264 to Pro Res for editing. The other footage shot with the Canon 6D was also optimized to Pro Res when it was imported into Final Cut Pro. So all the footage was compatible and seamless. Photographs can also be imported and optimized.
Editing a short documentary with Final Cut is a subject for another article. Final Cut Pro, once you understand how the program works, is not difficult. It facilitates editing creatively and quickly. For experienced editors there is an unlearning process that involves track based editing vs Final Cut’s non linear story structure editing. Whatever non-linear editing (NLE) program you use it’s important to have a plan.
James R (Jim) Martin, Documentary Filmmaker and Author Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia.
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
Here’s an example of a short documentary (Seven minutes) that went on to win a Tely Award.
Nominated for an Oscar in the Best Feature Length Documentary category 2015, Virunga, a Netflix movie, is a story that takes the viewer into the chaos of the war-torn Eastern Congo and Virunga National Park in the Congo, where dedicated Park Rangers struggle to protect the last of the Mountain Gorillas and preserve the park and its residents.
Poachers endanger the gorillas. Park rangers discover a massacre of gorillas by people trying to exterminate them for the land. Militia groups, including the rebel group M23, make war against the Congo government adding another layer of fear. International corporate entities interested in the rich natural mineral resources of the area, including drilling for oil in Virunga National Park, create a situation where Park Rangers and officials are at odds with SOHO the oil exploration corporation. While the humans fight for their piece of the pie, Verunga National Park, a UNESCO World Heritage site, and its inhabitants, animals of all types, become vulnerable. For some interests, the gorillas, and all the other animals are expendable.
One of the themes in the documentary involves three young orphaned gorillas rescued by the Park Rangers and now in their care. As the war encroaches on the park the care of the young gorillas becomes increasingly more difficult. Seeing these young gorillas and their affection for the Rangers is heart warming.
It seems that the animals and humans in and around Virunga face similar problems as the war engulfs their constant struggle for survival. This documentary does an excellent job of telling the story by being there in the park. The filmmakers are with the rangers, the oil company (SOHO) security, the indigenous people living in the area, government soldiers and rebels as events progress. The documentary shows the refugee camps on the southern border of Virunga Park where thousands of people are living displaced by the rebels and war. Interviews and conversations with certain characters seem to be done without the interviewees knowing it. This is a pretty risky tactic for the filmmakers if they are caught since value for a person’s life is low.
VIRUNGA combines nature documentary and journalistic reporting from a war zone. The filmmakers face many life-threatening situations as they go with Park Rangers through the park to check on the gorillas and other animals. The rangers must deal with poachers and rebel militias.
VIRUNGA is a story that demonstrates the cruelty and greed of humans and the humanity shown by a few people in times when all around them is made hostile.
VIRUNGA is a documentary film that brings into focus the realities of this area of Africa and perhaps sheds light on some of the problems facing many of the former European colonies in Africa. The indigenous people have no history of self-rule. Even with independence they are still fair game for exploitation by international corporate entities that can buy their way into these countries.
VIRUNGA — Directed by Orlando von Einsiedel, Produced by Joanna Natasegara and Orlando von Einsiedel, Cinematography Franklin Dow, Editor Masahiro Hirakubo. A NETFLIX FILM – 100 MINUTES – COLOR
Review by James R Martin, Documentary Filmmaker and Author Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia
Trailer
httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wxXf2Vxj_EU’
Virunga Available on NETFLIX
Links to books by James R Martin
[amazon_image id=”0982702361″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Actuality Interviewing and Listening: How to conduct successful interviews for nonfiction storytelling, actuality documentaries and other disciplines … (Documentary and Nonfiction Storytelling)[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”B0799P7HNJ” link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Listen Learn Share: How & Why Listening, Learning and Sharing can Transform Your Life Experience In Practical Ways[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
CREATIVITY – the perfect crime by Philippe Petit is an excellent documentary style nonfiction book that offers an amazing amount of insight into the author’s creative process and how the reader might adopt some of those ideas. “If you don’t know what the rules are, it is easier to break them.” “Go to extremes to shelter your creative process from negative influences.” — Philippe Petit – Creativity — the perfect crime.
Machu Picchu is one of those places I’ve always wanted to visit. While in the Army, Leon, and I went to the Boston Library and started researching a possible journey we could take when our enlistments were up. We were researching the Inca Trail and Machu Picchu. Of course we soon discovered that there was a train that went along the Inca Trail or to Machu Picchu. This took some of the adventure out of the idea. I think we thought the Inca treasure might still be out there.
Reading Mark Adams book Turn Right at Machu Picchu, all these years later has brought back not only the sense of adventure but also, after reading the book, a feeling that I’ve been there. Documentaries (nonfiction stories) come in all forms. Adams takes you step-by-step through his own experience and the history of Peru as it relates to the Inca civilization, the Inca Trail, Machu Picchu and other ruins in the area. The Inca civilization didn’t last that long, especially after the Spanish arrived in 1532. But the indigenous people of the Peruvian Andes, who speak Quechua, still live in the area around Machu Picchu and Cuzco.
A major part of the story evolves around Hiram Bingham III, who in 1911 basically brought Machu Picchu into the limelight along with the notion that it was the Lost City to which some of the Inca’s, with their
Hiram Bingham III
Gold and Silver treasures, retreated from the Spaniards. In 1913 National Geographic featured Bingham’s travels in one edition that brought Machu Picchu, Bingham and National Geographic into prominence. Bingham was a controversial character and went on later expeditions to Peru. According to Adams he may have been the inspiration for Indiana Jones character in Raiders of the Lost Ark. Adams layers the historical facts with his travel progress so that the book has a narrative cinematic quality. There are some well-drawn maps and black and white photographs included in the book. There is also a glossary that helps with pronunciation of some of the Quechua (Ketch-wah) names.
Mark Adams and John Leivers
Adams writes he “wanted to retrace Bingham’s route through the Andes on the way to discovering Machu Picchu” along with looking at other important locations. Turn Right at Machu Picchu is more than one man’s journey of exploration and discovery. It leaves you with a feeling that you’ve gone along on this adventure, done the research, heard the many stories, met the intrepid guide, John Leivers, who’s experience makes the journey possible, hiked the mountains, hiked the Inca roads and seen the awesome Apu (mountain) views. There’s also a supporting cast of characters including local Peruvian mule handlers, cooks and others.
Turn Right at Machu Picchu offers new appreciation and insights into Inca architectural and astronomical accomplishments. The Inca employed a method of building with stone and granite that, without the use mortar, brought the blocks together as flush as any modern building. The built hundreds of miles of small stone paved roads up and down mountains that connected various parts of their dominion. They aligned their cities by the stars and had buildings with windows that would capture the solstices on the proper days.
The Inca Trail
If you are planning a trip to Peru, Machu Picchu and the Inca Trail, Turn Right At Machu Picchu is a must read and might be something to stuff into your back pack. You can also be an armchair adventurer, this book will make you feel like you are there. No need for a TV, the words create the pictures.
Review by James R Martin – Author Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia
[amazon_image id=”0452297982″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Turn Right at Machu Picchu: Rediscovering the Lost City One Step at a Time[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
A look at the new Canon 7D Mark II, the new Atomos Ninja Star Pro Res recorder and how they can be used together to shoot Pro Res HQ 4:2:2 or 4:2:2 footage. Also how the Ninja Star can be used with the Sony A6000 to get equally great video with a relatively small package and price.
Technology, when it comes to photography, film and video, never ceases to amaze me. Advances in equipment and resources over the past forty-five years boggles the mind; if you consider what technology existed for professional production back in the 1970’s. If I had all this wonderful, relatively modestly priced gear back when I got out of film school… But that’s another story.
This story is about the new Canon 7D Mark II, the Ninja Star and the Sony A6000.
First Canon’s new 7D Mark II is a significant upgrade from the 2009 7D. It’s an amazing tool for both still photography and video production. As an owner of the original Canon 7D I thought long and hard about whether to upgrade to the 7D Mark II at about $1799 for the camera body. All my EF lenses are compatible with the new camera so I only need the body. I did consider a Canon 5D Mark III and/or it’s anticipated upgrades due out soon. But there is a big price difference.
I use the 7D for still photography and video. The still photography quality is excellent and the video is good. But I always felt the camera was primarily suited for still photography. Even after a firmware upgrade allowed the audio to be manually controlled, the camera sound recording was only suitable for a scratch track or home movies. But acceptable audio may be recorded externally working double system. With the right rig some decent documentary footage could be shot.
While waiting for the new Canon 7D Mark II to come out I bought a Sony Alpha a6000. This is an amazing, mirrorless DSLR (interchangeable lenses) that is very small but big on quality with 24.3MP APS-C Exmor APS HD CMOS sensor. It produces high-resolution photographs and full HD movies in low light with ISO sensitivity up to 25,600. Street prices for this camera with a lens are around five to six hundred dollars. The camera has complete manual or automatic shooting options and records HD 1080 Progressive or Interlaced footage at a number of frame rates. Great camera for shooting stills or video without attracting attention, however, audio still needs to be recorded on an external device like the Zoom H1, available for $99. This small digital recorder can be mounted on the camera’s hot shoe or handheld. One problem with mounting a recorder or microphone on a DSLR is it will pick up camera sounds like servomotors, auto focus and sounds made while zooming.
The Sony A6000 uses micro four-thirds lenses like the Black Magic Pocket Camera but the a6000 has a Sony E mount. An adapter can be purchased to convert the Canon EF mount to the Sony A6000, however, some functionality may be lost depending on the lens. The a6000 will also work with the Ninja Star.
I decided to buy the Canon 7D Mark II after looking at the specs and reviews of the camera. It seemed like it would be great for all types of production including still photography and digital video. One important aspect of the camera is the uncompressed output from the HDMI port on the camera.
My earlier experience and knowledge of the original Canon 7D was helpful, but more of an introduction to the Mark II. The little booklet that comes with the camera is a quick start guide but it’s necessary to download the User Manual from Canon to get really familiar with all the features and functions of the camera. You can set it on “Auto” and basically “point and shoot,” but that would be a waste of the amazing amount of potential the Canon 7D Mark II offers.
The Canon 7D Mark II is built to allow the shooter all kinds of options that can be programmed or accessed easily on the fly. The super 35mm, APS-C-sized 20.2MP CMOS sensor, and dual DIGIC 6 image processors make this DSLR well suited for all types of production. The Canon 7D Mark II has a 65-point all cross-type phase-detection Auto Focus (AF) system and Dual Pixel CMOS AF technology. This is ideal for accurate focusing for both the optical viewfinder and live view shooting. Live view shooting on the 3.0” LCD monitor is available for both still photography and video. It records full HD 1080p/60. Movie formats: H.264, .MOV, MP4 are all compressed formats. The HDMI output is uncompressed.
Photographs may be shot in .JPG and/or Raw. The compressed video (.MOV) quality is excellent and can be imported directly into Final Cut Pro or other editing software. With a high native ISO speed of 16,000 (expandable to ISO 51,200) you can shoot in very low light situations. There are white balance options, manual aperture, shutter options and menu options for the in camera video and the HDMI output. The camera has audio in and out as well as a built-in microphone. There are excellent in-depth reviews of the Canon 7D Mark II features online including B&H Photo.
Initial test shooting of stills and video (using double system sound) went well with a one-person handheld rig including a Zoom H1 recorder for the audio. The camera is easy to handhold even with one hand, but using a zoom lens and holding a recorder can be difficult. Mounting the H1 recorder on the hot shoe is an option if you turn off the Auto Focus. There are brackets that are available that allow the offset of the microphone or recorder. This may help to stop the recording of camera and lens focusing sounds. Disabling auto focus options in the camera menu can minimize the clicking the lens makes trying to focus on something. One option, for picking up ambient sound working hands free, might be to wear a lavaliere microphone and connect it to the camera or the recorder to pick up ambient sound away from the camera. Double system, recording audio separately, using a sound recordist, is the best idea.
Both the Canon 7D Mark II and the Sony Alpha a6000 are excellent cameras for certain applications. They produce stunning results and have advanced features on their own. Still if there is away to kick up the video quality and get uncompressed ProRes 4:2:2 footage, it seems a good idea. Up until recently one way to do this was to buy an Atomos Ninja 2 monitor/recorder for $695.00. The Ninja 2 is a fine device and can be used with many cine cameras including the Canon C100. But Atomos has come out with another smaller device without a monitor for $295 that is perfect for a DSLR like the Canon 7D Mark II, the Sony Alpha a6000 and a number of other cameras. (Other cameras supported)
The Atomos Ninja Star Pocket-Size ProRes recorder and deck is a great addition to the Canon 7D Mark II if you want to get professional HD ProRes footage to edit. Here are the basic specs:
Records 1080p 10-Bit, 4:2:2 via HDMI
ProRes HQ, 422, and LT Codecs
Micro HDMI Input & Loop Output
Stores to CFast Cards
Audio Line-In
Audio Level Indicators
Battery Life & Time Remaining Indicators
5 Hour Battery Life
Mounting Plate with 1/4″-20 Thread Holes
Lightweight at Only 4.6 oz
There are a number of settings that need to be correct on the Canon 7D Mark II before it will work correctly with the Ninja Star. The Ninja Star recognizes the Time code of the HDMI footage coming from the camera. So you need to have the Time code turned on and running. In addition the Record Command setting under Time code must be on. If all the menu settings are correct you can control the start and stop recording from the 7D Mk II start button.
Levitated Mass, directed by Doug Pray is a documentary that has appeal as an adventure story, exploration of the place of monumental art in America, the work of an artist with and alternative view of space and time, and it all revolves around a 900 million year old rock. Levitated Mass is the saga and implementation of an idea originally envisioned in 1968 by artist Michael Heizer.
Levitated Mass is a well-made documentary that both informs and entertains. Doug Pray’s previous documentaries include “Yelp.” “”Scratch,” “Big Rig,” and “Art & Copy” among others.Levitated Mass will keep you involved and finding answers to questions you may come up with while watching. This is a story about many things including art and how it relates to life for the artist and the audience.
The Levitated Mass adventure begins when Heizer finds a huge granite boulder, a survivor a 2005 quarry blast, that meets the vision he has had for the rock he wants to use for a monumental sculpture. Heizer contacts Michael Govan, Director of the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA) who agrees to take on the project, including moving the two and half story tall, 1.2 million pound rock to the museum site in LA County, from a quarry near Riverside, California 105 miles away. Moving something heavier than a 747 airplane over the roads and through 22 cities, each with their own laws and permitting process, is no easy task. But the journey, as seen in the documentary, engages the imaginations of thousands of people along the route. Interviews with spectators in various places along the way allows the documentary to explore how this part of the experience engages the public who now feel they are a part of this work. The “Rock” is a celebrity passing through town for all to see.
[box] “We’re living in a world that’s technological and primordial simultaneously. I guess the idea is to make art that reflects that premise.” Michael Heizer, Sculpture in Reverse 1984 [/box]
Moving the rock is only part of the story. A concrete space needs to be built for the installation to hold the rock, levitating so that people can walk under it and all around it. Through out the story Michael Heizer’s work, installations from all around the world are shown. In the process a fundamental understanding of his concepts of negative space and monumental sculpture comes across.
Levitated Mass documentary starts with a planned explosion at the quarry where the pure granite “rock” was born. When the dust settles in the private quarry near Riverside, California the rock and some back-story are introduced. Archival footage going back to a sculpture done by Heizer in 1969, in Bern, Switzerland and combined with interviews are important to the documentary in that they furnish insight into the seriousness of Heizer’s work and the philosophy behind it. His work controversial at times, too large for museum interiors; Heizer moved his work outside. He is perhaps the originator of what has come to be called “Land Art.”
A large part of the of the documentary is the preparation and actual moving of the “Rock” from the quarry near Riverside, California to the Los Angeles County Museum. A colossus transport vehicle 450 feet long is put together to hold and move the rock at a snail’s pace from city to city. Permits are required and the route must be planned so as not to destroy highways, bridges and overpasses along the way. This is a monumental journey even with modern equipment and resources. A reminder of what ancient civilizations may have faced moving non indigenous rocks to build Stonehenge or sculptures in Mexico.
Levitated Mass is an important and entertaining documentary on many levels. The pace, editing, cinematography and story bring new insights forward as well as questions about the role of art, in particular large sculpture, in the modern world. Also what will this current civilization leave behind for succeeding civilizations? What will be the modern pyramids, Stone Hedge or other edifices seen 500 or a 1000 years from now?
[amazon_image id=”0982702329″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Create Documentary Films, Videos and Multimedia: A Comprehensive Guide to Using Documentary Storytelling Techniques for Film, Video, the Internet and Digital Media Projects.[/amazon_image]
[amazon_image id=”0982702361″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Actuality Interviewing and Listening: How to conduct successful interviews for nonfiction storytelling, actuality documentaries and other disciplines … (Documentary and Nonfiction Storytelling)[/amazon_image]